diff --git a/apps.json b/apps.json
index 899390497..4dcfde342 100644
--- a/apps.json
+++ b/apps.json
@@ -1283,7 +1283,7 @@
     "name": "Numerals Clock",
     "shortName": "Numerals Clock",
     "icon": "numerals.png",
-    "version":"0.04",
+    "version":"0.05",
     "description": "A simple big numerals clock",
     "tags": "numerals,clock",
 	"type":"clock",
diff --git a/apps/numerals/ChangeLog b/apps/numerals/ChangeLog
index 927c4ff5f..855442377 100644
--- a/apps/numerals/ChangeLog
+++ b/apps/numerals/ChangeLog
@@ -2,3 +2,4 @@
 0.02: Use BTN2 for settings menu like other clocks
 0.03: maximize numerals, make menu button configurable, change icon to mac palette, add default settings file, respect 12hour setting
 0.04: Don't overwrite existing settings on app update
+0.05: Fix settings issue
diff --git a/apps/numerals/numerals.settings.js b/apps/numerals/numerals.settings.js
index 2d388525c..1e97271b6 100644
--- a/apps/numerals/numerals.settings.js
+++ b/apps/numerals/numerals.settings.js
@@ -11,7 +11,8 @@
     updateSettings();
   }
   let numeralsSettings = storage.readJSON('numerals.json',1);
-  if (!numeralsSettings) resetSettings();  
+  if (!numeralsSettings) resetSettings();
+  if (numeralsSettings.menuButton===undefined) numeralsSettings.menuButton=22;
   let dm = ["fill","frame"];
   let col = ["rnd","r/g","y/w","o/c","b/y"];
   let btn = [[24,"BTN1"],[22,"BTN2"],[23,"BTN3"],[11,"BTN4"],[16,"BTN5"]];
@@ -30,7 +31,7 @@
     onchange: v=> { numeralsSettings.drawMode=dm[v]; updateSettings();}
     },
     "Menu button": {
-      value: 1|btn[numeralsSettings.menuButton],
+      value: btn.findIndex(e=>e[0]==numeralsSettings.menuButton),
       min:0,max:4,
       format: v=>btn[v][1],
       onchange: v=> { numeralsSettings.menuButton=btn[v][0]; updateSettings();}